Media choice - Medialand digests another title

Media Guardian v Media Weekly

As I’m reliably informed in the launch issue of Media Weekly, fashion brands are the new brand thing (Lucy Aitken, page 11), I better ’fess up and lay my cards on the table. I am not a reader of The Independent. If The Guardian could supply all my reading needs I would let it. It doesn’t, so I don’t, but I do have a soft spot.

I came to Media Weekly therefore with no expectations. Good that there was to be another highly credible player commenting on the media, but would it be a readme too or would it be a read-me and an only read me? I like the cover of Media Weekly.

Yes, of course, these two publications exist to comment on the issues and strategies of media entities – who’s winning the circulation wars basically and, of course, battles to sell advertising.

Their focus is majorally the newspapers and we all know news papers are about serious matters.

However, as we also know, the media is about people.

And it’s here that I feel there is an interesting divergence. Media Guardian’s cover promised me participation in the great debate on the BBC’s purity as champion of public service broadcasting.

And the future of Panorama was the lead story. But in truth, a rather lacklustre logo of Panora- ma versus the future of The Daily Mail as discussed by Lord Rothemere – which promises a more gripping read? I’d say the latter, straight to the heart of power and our media.

Media Weekly’s cover sells its names strongly: Greg Dyke, Kelvin MacKenzie, Matthew Norman.

But Media Guardian sells the issues.

Yet the inside pages of Media Guardian seem to offer more of a read. By this I do not mean more weighty and more insightful, but more variety. In fact, more. Out of 14 editorial pages in the Media Guardian, there were some 17 pieces. In comparison, 21 editorial pages of Media Weekly offered 17 pieces.

I think this is what Media Weekly lacks as yet – a bit of pace The pages are often dedicated to one feature and I did feel as though some of them just went on too long. Harriet Harman would be the perfect example. “All political editors should ensure they have some women on their team and should groom them for political editorship.” Yes, right Harriet, just like that then. It feels like Media Weekly needs to be, well, a bit more media – more colour and drama.

Which leads on to design. As these are media pages, a plea: can we have some? Design that is.

Media Weekly is a touch dreary.

It is a dullard and a bludgeon in comparison to the neatness and lightness of the redesigned Media Guardian. So newspaper, particularly in its use, or non-use, of colour. I do like some of the attempts at the fripperies of media life – aka Inside Story – and I think some of the features in Media Weekly present a broader view of media – the Jane Root interview, for example. These do offer a longer read, but then Media Weekly has more editorial – something that is sure to change once/if the job classifieds take off.

So pockets aside, which publication will win media hearts? And there are a few to be won in magazineland since, although the influence of magazines is felt far and wide, in all types of media there is not enough acknowledgement of this in terms of column inches. So, more on magazines perhaps? In the meantime, I think I’ll be reading both.

Media Guardian 4 out of 5

Media Weekly 3 out of 5     


Review by Jane Wynn, Editorial Publisher River Publishing

Have your say...

Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus
Media Week Jobs
Search for more media jobs


Waitrose boosts content strategy with 'Weekend Kitchen with Waitrose' C4 tie-up

Waitrose boosts content strategy with 'Weekend Kitchen with Waitrose' C4 tie-up

Waitrose has joined forces with Channel 4 and produced a Saturday morning lifestyle and cookery programme called 'Weekend Kitchen with Waitrose', with TV presenters Lisa Snowdon and Steve Jones signed up to front it.

Newspaper ABCs: Guardian smashes through 100m browsers in March 2014

Newspaper ABCs: Guardian smashes through 100m browsers in March 2014

The Guardian reached more than 100 million monthly unique browsers for the first time in March, according to Audit Bureau of Circulations figures published today.

Toyota achieves the impossible by calming angry Roman drivers

Toyota achieves the impossible by calming angry Roman drivers

Italians swearing and shouting while sitting behind the wheels of their cars and negotiating the busy streets of Rome could become a thing of the past if they all start driving Toyota's Hybrid vehicles, implies a short film for the car brand.


Get news by email