Facebook is a lower quality medium than TV, says marketing academic

Advertiser should pay less to reach people on Facebook than on TV because the former skews mainly towards a brand's heaviest buyers, according to Professor Byron Sharp from the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute of South Australia.

Facebook: a lower quality advertising medium says Professor Byron Sharp
Facebook: a lower quality advertising medium says Professor Byron Sharp

Speaking at an event held by TV marketing body Thinkbox on Friday (23 March), Sharp said to grow, brands needed to reach people who didn't buy their category very often. However, Facebook fans "skew massively to the heaviest buyers, the people who are the easiest to reach".

Sharp said: "They see you more often, they notice everything you're doing. You should pay less to reach those people. TV reaches your normal category buying base, but earned media skews to your heaviest buyers. It therefore, is a lower quality media."

The Ehrenberg-Bass Institute is part of the School of Marketing at the University of South Australia and has one of the largest numbers of marketing scientists in the world. Its corporate sponsors include Coca-Cola, Unilever and Procter & Gamble.

Sharp said earned media such as Facebook was "very sexy at the moment" but it skewed towards heavy buyers of a product, while marketing tactics that skewed towards light buyers were of "great strategic value".

He said TV had a higher value than earned media because it reached a brand's normal category base, while higher rating TV shows were even more valuable because they had a higher proportion of people who were light TV viewers.

Presenting as part of an event for around 200 people from the media, marketing and advertising industry at Bafta in central London on Friday morning (23 March) Sharp said growth came from people who did not buy the category very often.

He said: "Big brands reach the people who don't buy the category very often – that's what big brands have managed to do. That what big brands are. A brand that's really small skews towards the category buyers."

To demonstrate how big brands were built by the people who bought them infrequently, Sharp used the example of Coca-Cola.

In 2005, British Coke buyers bought an average of 12 cans of Coke each, but Sharp said that figure was skewed by the people who drank Coke "morning, noon and night".

In fact, less than 5% of buyers bought 11 to 13 cans during 2005, and a typical Coke buyer (around half) only bought one or two cans over the entire year.

Sharp said: "Who is [the] typical buyer? If you're Coke it's them. That's half your customer base. And that's a big brand. All big brands have a skewed distribution like this, with the vast bulk of their customers down that end.

"It reminds us why Coke advertises. Because what do Coke ads say? They say 'Enjoy Coke'. They've said the same thing for decades. They spend an enormous amount of money telling us the same thing.

"Who is Coke advertising to? It's the millions of people down that end that buy a Coke once or twice a year. These are the people Coke needs to jump in front us and say: 'Hey, you know us – why don't you buy us?'"

Follow Maisie McCabe on Twitter @MaisieMcCabe

Have your say...

Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus
Media Week Jobs
Search for more media jobs


PHD co-founder Jonathan Durden reflects 25 years on

PHD co-founder Jonathan Durden reflects 25 years on

Who knew that a global phenomenon could be spawned from such humble beginnings? PHD co-founder Jonathan Durden takes a trip down memory lane.

Friday's lesson? We should all be more unprofessional

Friday's lesson? We should all be more unprofessional

What kind of time is 18:05 to you? Home time? Carry on working time? Bloody big glass of wine time? At Brand Republic we know it's often time to recoup, when the day's meetings are over and you can catch up on the most important developments of the day. Our 18:05 digest brings you the five things you need to know at the end of every day. Whether it's the top news stories, what's trending on social, what the wider media is saying or irreverent inspiration for your journey home - we've got it covered. And don't worry, we'll keep it short.

#MediaWeek30 set for bumper issue and party on 29 April

#MediaWeek30 set for bumper issue and party on 29 April

Media Week's 30th celebrations are taking shape, offering the chance for the UK's vibrant commercial media businesses to get involved.


Get news by email