Tube dispute is not about ad revenue, says CBS legal chief

CBS Outdoor would still have issues with the London Underground ad sales contract even if the revenue was high, according to CBS Outdoor's chief lawyer Richard Sauer.

London Underground: in dispute with CBS Outdoor
London Underground: in dispute with CBS Outdoor

Two weeks ago (25 August), CBS Outdoor made the surprise move of announcing it would serve notice on 1 October to terminate its ad sales contract with London Underground on 31 March 2012 unless it could agree new terms.

CBS Outdoor argues that the "massively delayed" Public Private Partnership construction projects on the London Underground denied it the opportunity to complete its upgrade work in a "timely fashion and within budget".

However, CBS Outdoor's attempts to renegotiate the terms of the contract have been the subject of speculation for some time, especially after it emerged that despite revenue declines, the money CBS Outdoor was paying LU was increasing.

Speaking to Media Week, Sauer, executive vice president and general counsel, CBS Outdoor, dismissed the suggestion that the current proceedings had anything to do with the fall in ad revenue in 2008/9.

Sauer said: "This is not about revenue, it is about construction costs and construction delays. We began talking in 2007 before the recession. This is about cost increases. It's not about general revenue consequences."

London Underground awarded CBS Outdoor the estimated £1bn ad sales contract, which is understood to be one of the biggest in the world, in 2006. The contract is due to run until 2015.

The dispute between the two parties deepened in April this year when it emerged that CBS Outdoor was planning to take London Underground’s parent group Transport for London to court to retrieve losses incurred by overrunning refurbishment work.

When questioned about Sauer's comments, a spokeswoman for London Underground reiterated its view that CBS Outdoor has no grounds to terminate the tube contract and that Transport for London continues to be engaged in discussions with the media company.

However, while Sauer agreed there have been conversations between LU and CBS he said the premise underlying these negotiations was not consistent as LU has refused to concede the delays constituted an "adverse event" under the terms of the contract.

CBS is currently seeking to meet with London Underground in the coming weeks to discuss whether the two parties can reach an agreement to renegotiate the contract ahead of its self imposed 1 October deadline.

Richard Parry, director of strategy at LU, said: "We do not accept that CBS is entitled to issue a termination notice and will be making it clear to CBS that it must honour its obligations under the contract."

The London Underground network will play an essential role in transporting more than five million visitors during the London 2012 Olympic Games next summer, which will put greater pressure to settle the dispute satisfactorily.

Sources close to other outdoor media owners said that while London Underground has not indicated it is looking for a new ad sales partner for the contract it has had already had some conversations with CBS Outdoor's rivals.

Have your say...

Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus
Media Week Jobs
Search for more media jobs


PHD co-founder Jonathan Durden reflects 25 years on

PHD co-founder Jonathan Durden reflects 25 years on

Who knew that a global phenomenon could be spawned from such humble beginnings? PHD co-founder Jonathan Durden takes a trip down memory lane.

Friday's lesson? We should all be more unprofessional

Friday's lesson? We should all be more unprofessional

What kind of time is 18:05 to you? Home time? Carry on working time? Bloody big glass of wine time? At Brand Republic we know it's often time to recoup, when the day's meetings are over and you can catch up on the most important developments of the day. Our 18:05 digest brings you the five things you need to know at the end of every day. Whether it's the top news stories, what's trending on social, what the wider media is saying or irreverent inspiration for your journey home - we've got it covered. And don't worry, we'll keep it short.

#MediaWeek30 set for bumper issue and party on 29 April

#MediaWeek30 set for bumper issue and party on 29 April

Media Week's 30th celebrations are taking shape, offering the chance for the UK's vibrant commercial media businesses to get involved.


Get news by email